Sigh...sadly I am actually starting to feel sorry for any one watching this new series without having either read Winston Graham novels or seen the 1970's series.
There's some thing tragically missing from this new adaptation. I have had mixed feelings from Episode 1 of Poldark 2. At first I liked it, then I wasn't sure, then I watched in another two times and I loved it. However as the weeks are going by, its more and more glaringly obvious that the new version is just missing the allurement that is my love for Poldark.
To start with the speed of which events are unfolding - it really feels like am watching highlights of a football match! There's no depth to the character development. I feel nothing for Elizabeth & Francis. I never saw the passion that Ross has/had for Elizabeth. Their "relationship" seems shallow, there's just nothing there. I remember a scene from the original where Ross was so passionate in his speaking to her (Elizabeth), we've had none of that. Its all just very superficial and hollow. Anyway back to Episode three, how can any one who hasn't had previous knowledge of the story-line get to grasps with what's really going on? I am sure new viewers do feel they understand, and perhaps they do - its just I feel they're only seeing this "Glossy" and "Smoothed" over version of events. Some characters parts are being completely omitted, for example Zachy Martin, who had a special friendship with Ross.
Secondly, I am getting increasingly bored with all these brooding scenes, of Ross gazing into the distance, and galloping horses across the coast. (I know that there was some of this in the first series). Furthermore, I am also not in the least interested in bare chested Aidan Turner - I don't feel that these scenes give any value whatsoever into the story, and I feel its unnecessary. It makes me feel that the wonderful story alone isn't engaging enough to bring in an audience without Aidan exposing himself. I would like to add I am a 32 year old woman, I am not denying Aidan isn't handsome. But Robin Ellis didn't need to appear as a sex symbol in the original series, and it worked because every one fancied him. I just don't think its necessary!
The seduction scene, just for me couldn't live up to the original - just thinking of when Angharad says "Do you think I'm pretty?", it was just so sweet and delightful to watch. I don't see the chemistry and passion between Ross and Demelza - its all moved too quickly with no explanation of why. I still can't warm to the new Demelza. All the new cast are good actors/actresses I am sure, but the magic is not there - at least not for me.
Also, I feel its worth adding, I am getting really fed up of being shot down in Facebook Poldark Discussion groups. It seems you can't state an opinion without some one telling "Not to watch if you don't like it"... yes that's really very construction and valuable to the conversation - thanks :) I don't wish to come across as too negative - I appreciate and respect every one's views, and like to discuss the finer detail and compare.
I absolutely LOVED Robin Ellis's (AKA the original Ross) performance in Episode 3. It was absolutely the highlight of the program for me. Although he's now of course older I can still see that sparkle in his eye, and for me he's still the true Ross.
The new version is obviously a very nice visual adaptation, and its more cinema style than play-write. It was always going to be different, and more modern. There's less dialogue, and more is down to interpretation. I am not completing slating the adaptation. It is of course very popular, so that in itself says something to its credibility.
I just sincerely hope that those unfamiliar with the original will discover the truly enchanting performance of Robin, Angharad, Jill, Ralph, Clive, Mary and Paul, not forgetting every one else who took part in the production. Saying all this I will still be tuning in next Sunday :)
(see my previous blog on Poldark here http://delightful-dragon.blogspot.co.uk/2015/03/all-things-poldark.html)